MDDUS joins call to retain doctors’ health route in GMC investigations
Author: MDDUS | Date: 17 September 2025
At a glance:
- MDDUS has joined other medical organisations in urging the UK Government to retain health as a category in fitness to practise investigations.
- The organisation warns proposed changes risk stigmatising doctors with health concerns, particularly in cases involving mental health.
- MDDUS says removing the health ground could discourage doctors from seeking help, with potential consequences for wellbeing and patient safety.
MDDUS is pleased to join the Medical Protection Society and 30 other organisations in urging the UK Government to retain health as a category of impairment in fitness to practise investigations.
We’re deeply concerned that anticipated changes to the Medical Act (1983) would treat doctors with a health concern, and who face an investigation by their regulator, as having “an inability to practice to a sufficient standard.”
We believe this is an unjust and pejorative way to view doctors – especially in GMC cases involving mental health.
Dr John Holden, Chief Medical Officer at MDDUS, said: “While we welcome the Government’s commitment to modernise medical regulation, dropping the health ground poses serious risks to both doctors and their patients.
“Health cases need to be handled sensitively. If this change goes ahead, doctors may feel discouraged from seeking help if their health is impacting their practice, potentially jeopardising patient safety.
“It also sends the wrong message at a time when doctors’ wellbeing should be a top priority for the Government.”
In January, our membership survey found that 21% of doctors had thought about self-harm or of taking their own life at least once during their career. A regulatory framework that overlooks health concerns could make this even worse.
This page was correct at the time of publication. Any guidance is intended as general guidance for members only. If you are a member and need specific advice relating to your own circumstances, please contact one of our advisers.
Elsewhere in MDDUS
FAQs
-
Who is MDDUS?
MDDUS is the Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland. It is a mutual organisation that supports doctors, dentists and healthcare professionals by providing professional indemnity, expert advice and representation, and by advocating on issues affecting medical and dental practice.
-
What is News.MDDUS.com for?
News.MDDUS.com provides news, insight and expert commentary on issues affecting doctors, dentists and healthcare professionals. It explains key topics such as wellbeing, regulation and workforce pressures, helping journalists, policymakers and stakeholders understand the challenges facing healthcare today.
-
Where can I find MDDUS membership information?
MDDUS membership information is available on the main MDDUS website. Visit www.mddus.com to find details about joining, member benefits, professional support services and official guidance for doctors, dentists and healthcare professionals.
-
How do I contact MDDUS with media enquiries?
Media enquiries should be directed to the MDDUS press team. Journalists can contact the MDDUS press team by telephone on 07976 886 552 or by email at press@mddus.com to request information, comment or expert insight.